Obituary for Paul Bevelhimer

Paul Bevelhimer

Paul E. Bevelhimer, 92, of Warsaw, Indiana, passed away into his Heavenly Father’s arms on Saturday, April 17, 2021 at 9:45 a.m. in The Estelle Peabody Memorial Home. Born March 14, 1929 in Anderson, Indiana, Paul was the son of Samuel and Neva (Leonard) Bevelhimer.

Paul was a 1947 graduate of Anderson High School, where he was a member of the 1946 IHSAA State Champion basketball team.  In 1951 Paul earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Education from Butler University, where he was a member of Delta Tau Delta fraternity, the Butler Sphinx Club, and a four-year member of the Butler University basketball team.  Upon his graduation, Paul began his career in education as an English teacher, guidance counselor and basketball coach at several Indiana schools, including Morristown, Shelbyville, Greenfield, Decatur, and North Miami High Schools.

A career change led Paul to the insurance industry where he was a General Agent for the Columbus Life Insurance Company.  During his 35 years as an agency owner, Paul earned countless awards and served thousands of families in Indiana and throughout the Midwest.

Although Paul left the coaching profession, he never stopped coaching. As a loving husband, father, grandfather and great-grandfather, he rarely missed an opportunity to support those he loved. Whether from the bleachers, a fishing boat, or while walking on the beach, Paul cherished time with his family, and we are all blessed to have received his “Coaching”!

Paul is survived by his loving wife of 47 years, Eve Bevelhimer of Warsaw.  He was preceded in death by his sister Juanita Hall of Anderson, by granddaughter Aly Tinker, and by Barbara Heiney Bevelhimer, his first wife with whom he had five children.

Also surviving are five children; Peggy (Sam) Coffman of Wabash, Susan Bevelhimer (Susan Tinker) of Muncie, Mark Bevelhimer (Shelaine Curd) of Oak Ridge, Tenn, Paula (Mark) Brown, of Logansport and Joe (Tracy) Bevelhimer of Indianapolis; one step-daughter, Janice Taylor of North Webster; 23 grandchildren, Cinnamon (Chad) Leavitt, Sarah (Mike) Anderson, Jared (Marie) Coffman, Kara (Mike) Ravenscroft, Andrew (Sarah) Coffman, Jesse (Katrina) Coffman, Garrett (Mallory) Coffman, Ben Coffman, Megan Tinker, Dylan Tinker, Nathan Bevelhimer, Samuel Bevelhimer, Megan (Frank) Fiore, Jacob (Allie) Brown, Alex (Cassie) Brown, Bryan Bevelhimer, Sydney Bevelhimer, Cody Bevelhimer, Chris (Khanh) Rooney, Scott (Casey) Rooney; Trisha (Seph) Jensen, Jenna (Jennifer) Rooney Germino, and Bethany Rooney; 46 great-grandchildren with one on the way; and 2 Great-Great Grandchildren.

A visitation will be held from 11:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. on Thursday, April 22, 2021 at First Christian Church, Warsaw. A funeral service will follow immediately at 1:00 p.m. at the church with Pastor Denny Bollenbacher officiating the service. Interment will be in Oakwood Cemetery, Warsaw.

Due to current COVID-19 recommendations, masks are suggested and social distancing is strongly encouraged.

Memorial donations may be made to the Butler University Fund for Student Scholarship:

Giving to Butler |


To Sign the Guestbook or Send a Condolence go to

Sign Guestbook or Send Condolences

If you would like to sign Paul Bevelhimer's guestbook, or send condolences to the family, please fill out the form below. We will make sure to add your name to the guestbook at the service, and/or send the family condolences on your behalf.

Due to the personal nature of condolences, they cannot be viewed on our website once submitted. Please call us with any questions at 574-267-7123. Thank you.